Have you tried one of these Preformed Niches?

Click on images to enlarge

HYDRO BAN® Preformed Niches are part of the expanded LATICRETE HYDRO BAN line of tile waterproofing products that allow for high quality rapid shower installations. These preformed niches are constructed of lightweight high-density expanded polystyrene with a waterproof finish and are ready to tile.

• Lightweight and durable. Easy to transport, handle and adjust during installation.
• Factory installed code approved waterproofing meets ANSI A118.10 requirements.
• Ready to tile!
• Multiple design options and sizes available adding utility and value to the shower installation.
• Component of LATICRETE Lifetime Warranty - Single source responsibility.
• Works in conjunction LATICRETE tile and stone installation materials.
• Made in America

Click here for more info